About Us

If you were to travel through the beautiful countryside in Lancaster County enjoying the sites and wonders of the Amish world, you would be sure to stop at the building with the huge windmill. Dutch Haven is Route 30’s original Amish crafts store, with distinctive local furniture, jams and jellies, and a broad array of gifts and souvenirs. Over 10,000 items in all!

Since 1946, Dutch Haven has been famous for America’s best Shoo-Fly Pie, and today it’s still produced from the original recipe. How famous? Featured in Time Magazine as the best Shoo-Fly Pie famous! Even people who think they don’t like Shoo-fly Pie fall in love with just one bite! Hundreds of pies are sold each week, both in the store and shipped across the country.

At the urging of our loyal customers, we now offer many of our favorites here on the web. We’re hoping that our many long-time loyal customers, as well as new customers, will enjoy strolling through our cyber store. Our friendly staff is on hand to answer any questions or to assist you. If you have a question please contact us.

Thank you for shopping at the Dutch Haven Online Store!